Tuesday, January 19, 2010

January 21 - News Stories Assessment

Anyone who hasn't finished their stories should complete and export them (directions on the board) today. For everyone who has finished, you will do the following:

1. You will make a post to your blogs today that includes a self-assessment of your story (copy and paste the information below).

2. You will do peer assessments of all of your classmates' stories. You need to write down two items that were done well and one item that could be improved for each person. Post these to your blog as well.

All of the stories are located here.



Broadcast Journalism Story Self-Assessment (Copy and paste this to your blog post)

Is the topic relevant and interesting? Does it relate to our audience? 1 2 3 4

Is the story angle clearly defined? Is it unique? 1 2 3 4

Is the stand-up informative and creative? Does it lead into the story? 1 2 3 4

Are the interviews important to the story? Experts? Restate question? 1 2 3 4

Are transitions smooth and informative? Sequence makes sense? 1 2 3 4

Does the story make sense? Does the A-Roll drive the story? 1 2 3 4

Do the camera shots add to the story? B-roll? Correct shots? 1 2 3 4

Is sound used to enhance story? Music? Natural sound? 1 2 3 4

Is the editing clean? Graphics? Sound? Transitions? 1 2 3 4

Is the story the proper time length? 1 2 3 4

Total ____/40

Comments: (What was done well? What improvements should be made?)

6 comments:

Unknown said...

Lethzee Calderon
comments on Tony Companion

Broadcast Journalism Story Self-Assessment (Copy and paste this to your blog post)

Is the topic relevant and interesting? Does it relate to our audience? 4

Is the story angle clearly defined? Is it unique? 4

Is the stand-up informative and creative? Does it lead into the story? 3

Are the interviews important to the story? Experts? Restate question? 4

Are transitions smooth and informative? Sequence makes sense? 4

Does the story make sense? Does the A-Roll drive the story? 4

Do the camera shots add to the story? B-roll? Correct shots? 4

Is sound used to enhance story? Music? Natural sound? 3

Is the editing clean? Graphics? Sound? Transitions? 4

Is the story the proper time length? 4

Total __38__/40

Unknown said...

Comments on Collins video

Broadcast Journalism Story Self-Assessment (Copy and paste this to your blog post)

Is the topic relevant and interesting? Does it relate to our audience? 4

Is the story angle clearly defined? Is it unique? 3

Is the stand-up informative and creative? Does it lead into the story? 4

Are the interviews important to the story? Experts? Restate question? 3

Are transitions smooth and informative? Sequence makes sense? 4

Does the story make sense? Does the A-Roll drive the story? 3

Do the camera shots add to the story? B-roll? Correct shots? 4

Is sound used to enhance story? Music? Natural sound? 2

Is the editing clean? Graphics? Sound? Transitions? 4

Is the story the proper time length? 4

Total ___35_/40

Jacob said...

comments on beattie

very nice effects

good story

needs better sound

Unknown said...

NICK TASCHNER

comments on beattie
1. good transitions from interview to interview
2. funny ending
improve on getting more b roll

comments on Hengel
1. nice titles on the interviews
2.great overall story, liked the ending
improve on getting better sound in the beggining.

comments on Hoffman
1. good b roll
2. had good transitions
improve on using less of the same clip.

comments on Johnson
1. good use of video effects with the dissapearing skater.
2. i like the titles on the bottom, there not to big and not to small
improve on shortening introduction

comments on kerber
1. good title
2. good b roll
improve on less b roll and getting more talking during the story

comments on Krueger
1. good interviews
2. good background noise
improve on getting a clearer shot, the video was a little blurry.

comments on Kuhn
1. the interviews were good with great shots
2. liked the pictures of dodgeball
improve on getting rid of that unwanted noise during stand up

comments on Mcalpine
1. good video transitions
2. liked the pictures with the interviews
improve on , there was a static sound the entire story

comments on Pederson
1. Liked the story topic
2. b roll was good
improve on better video quality

Jacob said...

comments on bierbaum
nice story
nice use of transitions
needs better volume control

Unknown said...

NICK TASCHNER


Is the topic relevant and interesting? Does it relate to our audience? 4

Is the story angle clearly defined? Is it unique? 3

Is the stand-up informative and creative? Does it lead into the story? 2

Are the interviews important to the story? Experts? Restate question? 4

Are transitions smooth and informative? Sequence makes sense? 3

Does the story make sense? Does the A-Roll drive the story? 3

Do the camera shots add to the story? B-roll? Correct shots? 3

Is sound used to enhance story? Music? Natural sound? 2

Is the editing clean? Graphics? Sound? Transitions? 3

Is the story the proper time length? 4